Your submission has been moved to the archive, although no confirmation email was received.

We occasionally experience issues with our email client, which may prevent the journal system from sending notifications to authors. If the status of your submission has changed from Active to Archived, it indicates that an initial review by the Editorial Board has been completed, and unfortunately, your manuscript has been rejected for not meeting one or more of our requirements:

• Non-compliance with Author Guidelines or a high similarity index (over 25%).
• Lack of scientific merit or insufficient contribution to research.
• Incompatibility with the journal’s scope and readership.
• Insufficient diversity in authorship or research area.
• Content issues, such as language errors, inadequate introduction, lack of a research gap or research questions, unclear aims, a literature review that does not thoroughly explore the topic, unsound methodology, poorly addressed results, lack of discussion, outdated references, or references not following APA 7th style.
• Significant AI-generated content (exceeding 50%).
• Prioritization of research articles; review articles are accepted by invitation only.

Due to the high volume of submissions, we are unable to provide additional details regarding this decision. We hope this outcome does not discourage you from submitting other relevant work to Shirkah: Journal of Economics and Business. Please note that rejected manuscripts cannot be resubmitted to this journal, and any such attempts will be disregarded. We encourage you to consider submitting your work to another journal.